Old West Lifestyle & Stories


On January 21, 1900 one of the Old West’s most intriguing and gruesome men died in a veterans’ hospital in California.  This was a strange ending for this man who was depicted in a movie Starring Robert Redford called “Jeremiah Johnson”.

John Johnson was a red bearded giant of a man who headed to the mountains when most mountain men were leaving them.

Early on Johnson came across a covered wagon that had been attached by Indians. The only survivor was the mother…and she had been driven mad from the experience.  Over the years John Johnson provided her with food.

The Indians left her alone because they felt she had been driven mad from the touch of the Great Spirit.

Johnson took a Flathead woman as his wife.  When he was away trapping, a Crow raiding party killed his wife, and the baby she was carrying.

This started the legend for which “Liver-Eating” Johnson is known. For 20 years Johnson took revenge against the Crow.  He supposedly killed as many as 300 Crow Indians, with a few Sioux thrown in for extra measure…And legend says he ate the livers of the Indians he killed.

Later “Liver-Eating” Johnson came out of the mountains, and joined the Union Army during the Civil War.  After the war, he was a deputy sheriff in Wyoming.

As he got older, Johnson made peace with the Crow Indians…And on January 21, 1900, he died in a veterans’ hospital in California.

Why did John Johnson eat the livers of the Indians? Was he a cannibal?…Technically, yes…But Indians often ate the raw liver of animals they killed.  They believed it would transfer the power of the animal to the hunter.  Maybe he wanted the Indians to think anyone who would do something this gruesome was touched by the Great Spirit.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *